Independent left newsContactSupport our work
The Explainer

The Shield Goes Up Before The Subpoenas Even Arrive

The pattern is this: with both chambers of Congress set to change hands in January, the administration is not preparing to answer questions. It is preparing to refuse them. The White House will not commit to complying with potential subpoenas from a Democratic-led Congress, and believes company executives who have had contact with the president may be covered by executive privilege. Asked whether it would comply, White House Counsel Will Scharf answered: It depends.

Read that plainly. Executive privilege is being stretched to cover not just the president and his staff but corporate executives who had contact with him. A doctrine meant to protect the counsel a president receives is being repurposed as a corporate liability shield — a way to keep the people who profited from access to this administration out of any witness chair the opposition might set up.

The timing is not incidental. The president announced this week that he would pursue legislation to boost the film industry alongside a group of Republican and Democratic senators — a staged show of bipartisanship offered precisely as his party loses Congress. Cooperation is the performance; the refusal to answer subpoenas is the policy. One is for the cameras. The other is being bolted quietly into place behind them. Even his vanity projects wear thin: a majority of Americans disapprove of his construction projects, which face opposition from his own party.

And the president has grown practiced at choosing which cameras to face. When the F.A.A. called a rare nationwide halt on flights, he stayed away from cameras, declining to appear while the country's air travel seized up, issuing social media posts about the entertainment industry and California's Democratic governor instead. A crisis in a core function of the federal government, and the man at its head substituted grievance and showbiz for presence. The instinct that keeps executives out of hearings keeps the president away from the podium when the questions might be hard.

This is how power operates when it expects to be investigated: it narrows the public's line of sight and widens its own exemptions. The cost of that narrowing does not fall on the administration. It falls on everyone downstream.

Consider who is being asked to fill out paperwork while executives are promised privilege. New Medicaid work requirements, set to take effect January 1, will mandate that many recipients complete burdensome new paperwork about their employment. The administration has paused the rules until mid-2027 — a reprieve, not a reversal. The obstacle course has been delayed, not dismantled. The accountability demanded of a poor person seeking health coverage is absolute; the accountability demanded of the powerful is negotiable, conditional, a matter of it depends.

That inversion is already measurable in the public's body. The United States has lost its measles elimination status, according to researchers with direct knowledge of the Pan American Health Organization's deliberations. A disease declared eliminated in 2000 is once again endemic. And for immigrant domestic workers, asserting the labor protections they are owed can bring dangerous forms of retaliation. The least powerful face retribution for claiming their rights; the most powerful are offered a privilege to avoid claiming responsibility.

That is the thread. An administration that answers to no one is building the legal machinery to keep it that way, distracting with film bills and feuds while the measles returns, the paperwork lands and the retaliation falls. The shield is going up. The question the incoming Congress will have to decide is whether it depends is an answer anyone is required to accept.